Rhetoric

In 1996, the Brazilian philosopher Olavo de Carvalho published a short, dense book titled Aristóteles em Nova Perspectiva: Introdução à Teoria dos Quatro Discursos (Aristotle in a New Perspective: Introduction to the Theory of the Four Discourses). Regardless of the controversies surrounding the author as a public figure, this book represents his most philosophically articulate contribution and deserves to be examined on its own terms. Its central thesis — that Aristotle’s Organon, together with the Rhetoric and the Poetics, forms a unified hierarchy of four types of discourse — engages real problems in the history of philosophy and shares ground with contemporary neo-Aristotelian readings by Pierre Aubenque, Enrico Berti, Alasdair MacIntyre and Martha Nussbaum. ...

Cicero Roman philosopher, orator, and statesman. The most important figure in transmitting Greek philosophy to the Latin world. His eclecticism synthesized Epicureanism, Stoicism, and the skepticism of the New Academy. He coined much of the Latin philosophical vocabulary — essentia, qualitas, moralis — that shaped all subsequent Western philosophy. Key Concepts Natural law: there is a universal moral law, grounded in reason, that transcends the positive laws of each people — the foundation of Western natural law theory Res publica: the republic as “the people’s affair” (res populi); the state is only legitimate when it serves the common good and respects the law Duty (officium): ethical life consists in fulfilling duties arising from reason, human social nature, and the roles each person occupies — systematized in De Officiis Academic probabilism: influenced by the skepticism of the New Academy, he argues that in the absence of certainty we should act according to what seems most probable (verisimile) Humanitas: the ideal of full human formation combining philosophy, rhetoric, and civic virtue; the Roman equivalent of the Greek paideia Highest good (summum bonum): debate among schools — for Stoics, virtue; for Epicureans, pleasure. Cicero leans toward Stoicism but presents arguments from all schools Influenced by Plato and Aristotle — politics, ethics, theory of knowledge Zeno of Citium — Stoicism (cosmopolitanism, natural law, duty) Epicurus — addressed critically Carneades — skepticism of the New Academy Influenced Augustine and all medieval philosophy — Latin vocabulary and natural law Thomas Aquinas — natural law theory Machiavelli, Montesquieu, Rousseau — republican theory Locke and Kant — natural rights and moral duty Renaissance humanism — ideal of humanitas Works On the Republic (De Re Publica, 54 BC); On the Laws (De Legibus, 52 BC); Tusculan Disputations (Tusculanae Disputationes, 45 BC); On Duties (De Officiis, 44 BC); On the Nature of the Gods (De Natura Deorum, 45 BC). ...

Gorgias A native of Leontini, in Sicily, Gorgias lived, according to tradition, more than a hundred years (c. 483–375 BCE). He came to Athens in 427 BCE as ambassador of his city and dazzled the Athenians with a new oratorical style, full of figures and rhythms — becoming the most celebrated and highly paid master of rhetoric of Antiquity. Alongside Protagoras, he is the great figure of the first generation of the Sophists. ...