Conservatism: Burke, Tocqueville, Oakeshott, Scruton, and the Philosophy of Tradition
Disposition, Doctrine, or Ideology? Conservatism is a tradition of political thought defined, to a large extent, by an attitude toward social change: prudence in the face of sweeping reform, esteem for inherited institutions and customs, and skepticism about the capacity of abstract reason to redesign society. There is a basic controversy over its status. For some authors it is a disposition or temperament that cannot be reduced to a program (Oakeshott’s thesis). For others it is an ideology with content of its own (authority, hierarchy, transcendent order, property), as in Russell Kirk and Roger Scruton. Samuel Huntington, in “Conservatism as an Ideology” (1957), proposed yet another reading, a situational one: conservatism is the defense of whatever established order is under threat, not a fixed set of beliefs. All three readings will prove useful below. ...