Sertillanges's The Intellectual Life: Study as a Vocation, Its Conditions and Its Methods

Can someone who is not a scholar by profession lead an intellectual life? The book that answered that question best in the twentieth century is short, practical, and almost austere: The Intellectual Life: Its Spirit, Its Conditions, Its Methods, published in 1921 by the Dominican friar Antonin Sertillanges. More than a hundred years later it is still read — entirely outside any religious context — as the finest manual of the ethics and discipline of study ever written. This article surveys its central theses, following the very structure announced in its subtitle: the spirit, the conditions, and the methods of intellectual work.

1. The author and the legacy of Thomas Aquinas

Sertillanges (1863–1948) was professor of moral philosophy at the Institut Catholique de Paris and one of the great interpreters of Thomas Aquinas. The book began as a free commentary on a short text on study traditionally attributed to Aquinas — the De modo studendi (or Epistola de modo studendi), the letter to a certain “Brother John” that enumerates the so-called Sixteen Precepts for Acquiring the Treasure of Knowledge. Sertillanges does not confine himself to literal commentary: he takes these medieval counsels as a starting point and reworks them into a modern treatise, yet the spirit remains Thomist through and through — the intelligence ordered toward truth, the unity of knowledge, the harmony of faith and reason.

2. The spirit: study as a vocation

The book’s founding thesis is that intellectual work is not a trade but a vocation. To study seriously engages the whole person — their morality, their will, their character — and not merely their technique. Hence the demand, central in Sertillanges, for an inner uprightness: the intelligence reaches truth only if the seeker is honest, humble, and disinterested.

The first condition of the spirit is therefore moral, not cognitive. The vain, the hurried, the one who studies in order to shine or to defeat rivals corrupts the very instrument with which they think. The virtues Sertillanges asks of the intellectual are severe: humility before a truth that is greater than we are, patience, perseverance, an honesty that prefers truth to personal success, and a kind of chastity of attention — refusing to scatter oneself, refusing to sell out to applause. Study, in this sense, is an asceticism.

3. The conditions: time, solitude, silence, and the body

The most famous part of the book is here — and it is also the most encouraging.

The “two hours a day”

Sertillanges holds that you need not be a full-time scholar to produce serious work. Someone with a profession, a family, unavoidable obligations, can nonetheless build a real intellectual life provided they set aside, every day, a few hours — two will do — protected, steady, and well used. The secret lies not in the number of hours but in their continuity and their quality: two faithful hours, day after day, year after year, build a body of work that heroic but scattered marathons never could. It is a deeply democratic argument — it opens the life of the mind to those who cannot make it their profession.

Solitude and silence

Thinking requires withdrawal. Sertillanges defends solitude not as misanthropy but as a condition of concentration: the intellectual needs hours in which they subtract themselves from noise, from visitors, from idle talk. Inner silence — the stilling of the passions and of haste — is the soil from which thought draws its nourishment.

The body in the service of the spirit

Here is a trait that surprises those expecting a “spiritualist” book: Sertillanges devotes whole pages to the body. Thought has physical conditions — enough sleep, a sober diet, exercise, fresh air, a steady rhythm of life. To mistreat the body is to mistreat the intelligence that depends on it. The intellectual life is also a hygiene.

4. The methods: reading, note-taking, creating

The art of reading

Against indiscriminate voracity, Sertillanges’s rule is to read little, but read well. Rank your reading; prefer the great books to many books; reread the masters rather than chasing novelties; and above all, read actively — questioning, resisting, conversing with the author rather than passively absorbing. Reading is a means, not an end: it serves to nourish one’s own thinking, not to replace it.

The work of memory and of notes

Sertillanges insists on the discipline of taking notes and of training the memory. The intellectual organises what they gather — index cards, notebooks, classifications — so that the material is at hand at the moment of creation. Erudition heaped up in disorder is useless; what counts is knowledge assimilated, made one’s own substance.

Creation and writing

The end of the whole journey is to produce — to think for oneself and to give form to what one has thought. Sertillanges treats the moment of composition, the courage to write, the patience to revise. The intellectual life culminates in a work, however modest; study that never issues in creation risks being mere consumption.

5. Why Sertillanges is still read

At first glance, a Thomist book from 1921 on the method of study would seem dated. The opposite is the case. In a culture of notifications, infinite scrolling, and fragmented attention, Sertillanges’s demands — solitude, silence, continuity, slow reading, the refusal of dispersion — sound almost subversive. One need not share his metaphysics to recognise the value of his diagnosis: the life of the mind is fragile and demands deliberate protection. That is why the book is read today by students, researchers, writers, and professionals of every kind, far beyond the confessional borders within which it was born.

6. Assessment

The Intellectual Life promises neither genius nor shortcuts. It promises something sturdier: that a serious life of the mind is within reach of anyone who truly wants it, provided they accept its conditions — discipline, humility, protected time, a cared-for body, ordered reading. The most enduring lesson may be the rule of the two hours: it is not extraordinary talent but daily fidelity that builds a body of work. In an age of scattered attention, it is one of the most necessary.

Essential reading

• Antonin Sertillanges, The Intellectual Life: Its Spirit, Its Conditions, Its Methods (1921).
• Thomas Aquinas, De modo studendi (the letter to Brother John — the Sixteen Precepts), the text that inspired the book.
• Antonin Sertillanges, Saint Thomas d’Aquin (2 vols., 1910), for the author’s Thomist background.

← Articles